Provider profile
On-A-Roll Contracting LLC
Provider snapshot
What this listing says
Northern NJ homeowners dealing with water damage who want one contractor to handle mold remediation, drywall rebuild, and the insurance claim paperwork.
Best for
- Homeowners in Kinnelon, Montclair, Ridgewood, or surrounding Morris and Passaic County towns needing post-water-damage restoration.
- Anyone juggling an insurance claim who wants the contractor to handle adjuster communication and claim documentation.
- Buyers who need both mold remediation and the rebuild work done by the same company rather than coordinating two contractors.
- Homeowners needing drywall, plaster, or ceiling repair after a leak, burst pipe, or flood.
- First responders or seniors looking for a restoration contractor that offers discounts.
About this company
On-A-Roll Contracting is a Kinnelon, NJ restoration company founded by Jeff O'Connell, who started in carpentry and painting before expanding into full home restoration. The company brands itself as "The Drywall Doctor" and has over 20 years of experience. Mold remediation is a newer addition to their service list, sitting alongside their core water damage restoration, drywall repair, and interior painting work.
What stands out here is the insurance claims assistance. Multiple reviewers describe Jeff working directly with their adjusters, documenting damage, and helping navigate the claims process at no extra charge. The website lists containment barriers, HEPA vacuums, dehumidifiers, and antimicrobial treatments for mold work. They also offer discounts for first responders and seniors.
Jeff runs a small crew that includes Alex and Brandon, with Jeff personally overseeing most projects. Reviewers consistently mention the team wearing booties, cleaning up daily, and leaving spaces looking new. Several customers have hired them for multiple insurance claims over the years.
A 5.0-star rating across 126 Google reviews is rare for any contractor. Zero negative reviews appeared in the last 18 months. That track record suggests a company that either resolves problems before they reach Google or genuinely delivers consistent work at this scale.
Services
Service area
Based in Kinnelon, NJ. Lists 18 towns across Morris, Passaic, Bergen, Sussex, and Essex counties including Montclair, Ridgewood, Wayne, Morristown, Clifton, Paterson, Oakland, Ramsey, Rockaway, Sparta Township, Stanhope, Dover, Livingston, Franklin Township, West Milford, Short Hills, and Upper Saddle River. That covers a wide geographic spread across northern New Jersey.
Review consensus
Jeff O'Connell gets named in nearly every review. Reviewers praise his responsiveness to calls and texts, his willingness to walk homeowners through insurance claims, and the attention to detail on drywall and painting finishes. Alex draws praise for efficiency and respectfulness. Multiple reviewers mention the crew wearing booties, cleaning up each day, and leaving spaces looking untouched. Repeat customers are common, with several reviewers noting they hired On-A-Roll for a second or third insurance claim.
0 found across 126 total reviews at 5.0★. No negative reviews appeared in the 18-month review window. There is nothing to report from recent complaint data.
Jeff O'Connell (owner — praised in nearly every review for communication, insurance help, and craftsmanship). Alex (crew member — praised for efficiency, precision, and respectfulness by Honielette Joan Rapp, Jenny Zaloum, Elizabeth Karl, Jennifer Koldyk, Harold Valdivia Garcia, Andrew Barker). Brandon (crew member — praised for drywall work by Jennifer Koldyk). Shawn (crew member — thanked by Angela Cordova).
126 reviews with a perfect 5.0-star average and zero recent complaints is an unusual record. Ask for Jeff directly when you call. If your project involves an insurance claim, this company has a strong track record of managing the adjuster relationship. Confirm their mold remediation experience separately from their drywall and rebuild work.
Keep in mind
- On-A-Roll does both mold testing and mold remediation. That creates a conflict of interest: the same company that identifies the mold problem also profits from fixing it. Ask whether they accept third-party test results or recommend an independent inspector.
- Their roots are in drywall and painting. Mold remediation is a newer service addition. Ask how long they have been performing mold-specific work and what training Jeff's crew has completed.
- The about page says they work with local mold and water remediation companies to repair homes after those companies remove water and mold. That framing suggests their primary role is reconstruction, not initial mitigation.
- They list 18+ towns across Morris, Passaic, Bergen, Sussex, and Essex counties. Confirm they will travel to your specific location without added charges.