Provider profile
All Claims Repairs
Provider snapshot
What this listing says
Deerfield Beach homeowners dealing with insurance claims for water or mold damage who want one company to handle everything from extraction through rebuild.
Best for
- Broward County homeowners who need mold remediation and reconstruction handled by a single contractor through an insurance claim.
- Property owners facing water damage emergencies who need same-day extraction and drying equipment deployed.
- Buyers who want a company with a Florida Mold Remediator license and General Contractor license under one roof, so the rebuild happens immediately after remediation.
- Commercial property managers in South Florida or the Cincinnati area who need a restoration company with multi-state offices.
About this company
All Claims Repairs is a Deerfield Beach-based restoration company that handles water damage, mold, fire, and storm recovery. They do both mold inspection and remediation in-house, along with the full rebuild afterward. The company also operates offices in West Chester Township and Columbus, Ohio.
The mold side includes containment, HEPA air scrubbers, damaged material removal, and post-remediation verification. They use thermal imaging and moisture meters for detection. On the rebuild side, they handle flooring, drywall, cabinetry, and painting. They work directly with insurance adjusters and also take out-of-pocket jobs.
The company has been in business for over 40 years, holds a Florida General Contractor license and a Florida Mold Remediator license, and follows IICRC standards. Their estimators carry Florida Adjuster licenses. They belong to the South Florida Claims Association and hold EPA Lead-Safe certification.
At 4.7 stars across 148 Google reviews, the rating holds up well for a restoration company. Most positives specifically name their project manager and describe the finished work, which suggests the praise is earned rather than generic.
Services
Service area
Headquartered in Deerfield Beach, Florida at 426 SW 12th Ave. Serves Broward County, Palm Beach County, and Miami-Dade County in Florida. Also operates offices in West Chester Township, Ohio (serving Butler, Hamilton, Warren, Montgomery, Clermont, Greene, Darke, Miami, and Franklin counties) and Columbus, Ohio, with coverage extending into Boone, Kenton, and Campbell counties in Kentucky and Dearborn County in Indiana.
Review consensus
Scott Blair is the most frequently named project manager across the review history, praised for responsiveness, honesty, and quality craftsmanship on rebuilds. Kirk draws recent praise for keeping appointments, showing up on time, and going beyond the claim scope to fix a subfloor at no extra cost. Paul Schuler is named repeatedly for coordinating multi-trade jobs and staying in close contact with homeowners. Joe Santore, Francisco, Roberto, Kenny, and Hilario all receive individual praise for detail orientation and respectful communication. Multiple reviewers mention the company educated them on mold prevention and content cleaning. The Florida and Ohio offices both generate positive reviews.
4 found across 148 total reviews at 4.7★. Vicki Taylor reported the company's pricing exceeded her insurance payout, leaving a large out-of-pocket bill four months after a fire with no resolution. The owner responded that estimates use industry-standard software and that carriers control payments. Marilyn Galvez described a mold remediation and bathroom repair that stretched from one month to nearly four, with her first floor flooding during the contractor's work, cabinet damage, and paint debris on belongings. The owner gave a personalized response acknowledging the issues and confirming punch-list corrections were underway. Jose Fonseca, a Local Guide with 108 reviews, named Tony Allogia specifically for failing to respond to emails requesting a code-required second water barrier on a roof replacement. The owner response to both Jose's and J Guertin's text-free one-star review used identical template language.
The owner responds to 100% of recent negative reviews, but the quality varies. Marilyn's complaint received a substantive, personalized reply that acknowledged shortcomings. Vicki's got a semi-template response redirecting to a phone number. Jose and J Guertin received word-for-word identical template responses. This inconsistency suggests the company takes some complaints more seriously than others, or that different staff handle reputation management.
Scott Blair (project manager — praised repeatedly across years for responsiveness, honesty, craftsmanship). Kirk (project manager — praised for keeping appointments and going beyond claim scope). Paul Schuler (project manager — praised for coordination and communication). Joe Santore / Joseph Santore (project manager — praised for smooth project management and detail orientation). Francisco (crew lead — praised for detail-oriented construction work). Roberto (contractor — praised for flooring and cabinetry). Kenny (technician — praised for mold/water remediation work). Hilario (technician — praised for remediation and communication). Kristy (office staff — praised for guiding a customer through the process). Aaron (crew — praised alongside Ohio office work). Sandro Campbell (crew — praised for attention to detail). Jeff Ardolino (project manager — praised for mold team response and communication). Owen Blandford (crew — praised for mold remediation work). John Fontana (staff — praised for honesty and communication after Hurricane Milton). Tony Allogia (staff — criticized for not responding to emails about code requirements).
Ask for Scott Blair or Kirk as your project manager if you are in Florida. Get a written scope and cost comparison against your insurance estimate before signing. If your project involves both mold removal and reconstruction, ask for a timeline commitment in writing and request regular progress updates, since the one extended-timeline complaint suggests oversight gaps can occur on complex jobs.
Keep in mind
- They do both mold testing and mold remediation. This is a conflict of interest. A company that finds the mold also profits from removing it. Consider getting an independent mold assessment before committing to their remediation scope.
- Two recent one-star reviews describe insurance billing disputes where the company's pricing exceeded what the carrier would cover, leaving homeowners with unexpected out-of-pocket costs. Ask for a written breakdown of costs vs. insurance coverage before work starts.
- One detailed complaint describes a bathroom mold remediation project that expanded from one month to nearly four, with flooding caused by the contractor's own work and repeated rework. The company acknowledged the issues and completed a punch list.
- Their service area claims span Florida, Ohio, Kentucky, and Indiana across three offices. Confirm which office and crew would handle your project, especially if you are outside Broward, Palm Beach, or Miami-Dade counties.